﻿﻿ MatPlus.Net

Website founded by
Milan Velimirović
in 2006

10:28 UTC
 ISC 2021

Remember me

 CHESS SOLVINGTournamentsRating lists1-Oct-2021
 B P C F

MatPlus.Net Forum Threemovers symmetrical can be excellent

### symmetrical can be excellent

I would like to show a wonderful symmetrical problem.
Two systems of black correction launch a double masked black half-pin.
I very like it.

I. I. Antipin
4th C Olympic Tournament 1990
(= 9+9 )

#3
Solution:
1.Qe8! ~ 2.Re1+ Kf3 3.Qh5#
1...Sh~ 2.Bf4+ Rf4 3.Sd5#
1...Sf6 2.Sf5+ ef5 3.Bf4#
1...Sb~ 2.Bd4+ Rd4 3.Sf5#
1...Sd6 2.Sd5+ ed5 3.Bd4#
cycle AB-BC-CD-DA

Yes, I agre with You and this is wonderful problem.
In chess problems, harmony is all about analogy. I dont know why is symmetry, as "geometrical analogy" considered as a flaw, only becouse of hers visual character.

Because symmetry may be boring: almost by definition,
symmetry doesn't show anything new. In this case, of course,
*the complete* variants show a cycle and thus, something

Hauke

Symmetry by itself is boring and uninteresting. Why then do we feel something totally different here?
My explanation goes like this:
The two symmetrical parts actually complement each other to create a far from trivial 4-fold cycle. Consequently, what might have remained two disconnected, tedious parts is actually converted into a wonderful whole. The surprise created by the gap between expectation and actuality has its own special value as a paradox.
Vive la petite différence!