|(1) Posted by Eugene Rosner [Wednesday, Dec 26, 2012 15:58]; edited by Eugene Rosner [12-12-26]|
let's look at Peter's #2!
Seasons greetings everyone!
This is a particularly beautiful problem, made in the day(I believe!) when twinning was particularly in vogue(perhaps the end of the period...) So the first question: Is the composer named Peter or Fritz? (Is the latter a nickname?) and does his last name officially end with one or two "n"s?
1PR. Die Schwalbe
(= 13+3 )
#2 B.f3S to c6
A.Qe8 f6,f5,fe,fg 2.Qa4,Bh5,Qxe6,Qxg6
changed pickaninny with a 5th change for unguarding e5 the right way.
1.Is hiding the Q diagonally behind the bP the most common way of generating a Pickaninny?
2.what do you think of the pinning mechanism?!
3.this is a zugzwang-do the few non-thematic variation duals bother you?
4.the W battery only generates one mate, but the rook is employed to protect the K-your thoughts on this construction?
|(2) Posted by Arno Tungler [Wednesday, Dec 26, 2012 16:58]|
See on http://www.berlinthema.de/ the (electronic) book of Erik Zierke "Der Reiz des Ungewöhnlichen – Ausgewählte Schachaufgaben von Peter Hoffmann." The author is quite critical of that 2-mover that is given on page 7. He says (in my express translation...)
The (B01) shows four changed mates after a Pickaninny. The judge said that "previous presentations had constructive weaknesses, here the task is shown brilliantly". Openly: My understanding of "brilliant" means at least a performance without twinning! Second, the way how the twins are given is not uniform as on f3 the knight not only blocks the queen (as on c6) but additionally protects the square g5 (relevant for the changed mate after fxe6). And third, the changed mate after 1... f6 is only a pseudo-change.
So, here you have already some answers for your questions by Erik Zierke. My opinion is more positive, I think the task is so difficult that the presentation is amazingly clean and harmonious.
|(3) Posted by Hauke Reddmann [Wednesday, Dec 26, 2012 20:45]|
<mode=bitching> My personal experience is: To get an applause from Erik Zierke,
you have to press a gun against his temple first :-)</mode>
|(4) Posted by seetharaman kalyan [Wednesday, Dec 26, 2012 21:20]|
The e-book cited, contains some outstanding problem of Peter Hoffman. Great composer.
|(5) Posted by Siegfried Hornecker [Friday, Dec 28, 2012 02:32]|
It is Peter Hoffmann from Braunschweig. Not to be confused with Fritz Hoffmann from Weißenfels.
|(6) Posted by Eugene Rosner [Friday, Dec 28, 2012 04:15]|
and where is Martin Hoffmann from?!
|(7) Posted by Siegfried Hornecker [Friday, Dec 28, 2012 04:47]|
Martin Hoffmann is from Zürich. Which can easily be seen in the Schweizerische Schachzeitung.
|(8) Posted by Eugene Rosner [Friday, Dec 28, 2012 05:37]|
so there are 3 important Hoffmanns?!
|(9) Posted by Hauke Reddmann [Friday, Dec 28, 2012 19:52]|
It's not THAT rare a name, such accidents happen.
(Positively scary it gets when I tell you that in the
German USENET jokes newsgroup there were even four to
five Hoffmanns posting regularly :-)
No more posts
MatPlus.Net Forum Twomovers let's look at Peter's #2!